Baker Street Wiki
Baker Street Wiki
Fu Manchu

Fu Manchu first appears in a series of novels by British author Sax Rohmer, the first of which, The Mystery of Dr Fu-Manchu (aka: "The Insidious Dr Fu-Manchu" in the US), was published in 1913.

He is of the most feared (and often controversial) characters to come out during the early years of the 20th century. Fu Manchu, the 'Devil Doctor', has terrorized the world of literature for decades since his initial appearance in Sax Rohmer's books. He has directed his wrath, and dreams of conquest, against the Western World due to (according to him at least) the long and tumultuous history of foreign influence and intervention in his native land.

The brilliant mastermind of a vast criminal network (the Si-Fan) made up of various agents and assassins culled from every corner of the global underworld. Despite his aggressive ways, the good Doctor despises guns and explosives, having a preference for poisons (either manufactured or from nature itself) and other ancient/silent forms of murder.

His chief nemesis is Sir Denis Nayland Smith (an ex-colonial commissioner turned Scotland Yard agent) and his own companion, Dr Petrie (a sort of Holmes/Watson duo of the series). Smith was largely the brawn to match Manchu's brains, and after many battles the two began to have begrudging respect for each other despite their differences.

Fu Manchu vs Sherlock Holmes[]

Despite the popularity these two have shared (at various points in time) over the decades, Sherlock Holmes has rarely clashed with the Devil Doctor.

The most well-known example is Ten Years Beyond Baker Street published in 1984 and written by Cay Van Ash. Taking place during an apparent chronological gap between "Hand of Fu Manchu" and His Last Bow (both published at the same time in 1917), where Dr Petrie turns to a retired Holmes to help him when Denis Nayland Smith is kidnapped by Fu Manchu's agents.

Then there's the unpublished/lost novel The League of Dragons by George Alec Effinger that would've been set during Holmes' university days, and an encounter he had with Fu Manchu. Chapters of this unauthorized book have been published in various Holmes anthologies since the 90's (Sherlock Holmes in Orbit and My Sherlock Holmes for example).

Then there's 2005's Elemental, querido Chaplin by Rafael Marin, a Spanish-language story that apparently presents itself as an unpublished manuscript in which actor Charlie Chaplin tells of how, as a poor youth in London, he helped Sherlock take on Fu Manchu.

Despite this small list of examples, the number of times that the Holmes-Manchu universes have crossed over/intersected doesn't end there.

  • It is the feud between Fu Manchu (aka: the 'Doctor' or 'Devil Doctor' due to copyright reasons) and Professor Moriarty for control of the element 'cavorite' that is the driving force behind the main story of Volume 1 of Alan Moore's The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen comic series.
  • While never named by name, (again, copyright reasons) Fu Manchu (and his Si-Fan network) makes multiple appearances in Kim Newman's novel Moriarty: The Hound of the D'Urbervilles.
  • The original idea for Clive Reston, ally for Marvel's Shang-Chi (rebellious son of Fu Manchu) the 'Master of Kung-Fu', was to have him be the grand-nephew of Sherlock Holmes. But due to Marvel not owning the rights to do so, it is only broadly hinted at (or ignored).
  • Jack L. Chalker's An Informal Biography of Scrooge McDuck, from 1974, was inspired by the similar attempts of Sherlock Holmes enthusiasts to recount the biography of a larger-than-life fictional character as though he were a historical figure, in the context of Holmesian Speculation. In allusion to this inspiration, an incident during which McDuck apparently teamed up with Holmes to fight "a certain oriental Doctor" is mentioned, with Chalker stating that further elaborations on this showodwn (referred to the Adventure of the Trained Cormorants) are "still awaiting elaboration in The Whole Art of Detection", being heretofore kept unprinted due to "the illustrious nature of the three men involved" and because "the Doctor got away".


In recent times the character of Fu Manchu has been considered by many to be a racist stereotype.[1]


  1. The racist curse of Fu Manchu back in spotlight after Chevrolet ad, Ian Young, South China Morning Post, 3 May, 2013, 6:10pm.